COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) – A list outlined by Yelp reveals what the company considers to be the best pizzerias in the Columbus area as of early 2025.
Taking the No. 1 spot is Fibonacci’s Pizzeria, located at 3055 Indianola Ave. in South Clintonville. The restaurant offers Neapolitan-style and pan pizzas with garnishes such as hot honey and balsamic glaze, as well as a variety of vegan toppings. The pizzeria also serves appetizers, sandwiches and salad. Reviews praise its “creative” and “delicious” pizzas.
Coming in second place is Pizza Nerds, located at 1376 Cherry Bottom Road in Gahanna. The eatery’s pies feature edge-to-edge cheese, sauce drizzled on top of the cheese and toppings. Along with pizza, the restaurant serves garlic bread, salad and cookies.
“Highly recommend Pizza Nerds: the pan pizza is so delicious, with crispy crust and perfectly thick dough, covered with exciting flavor combinations of toppings,” one Yelp-user wrote. “We will be ordering from here often and telling our friends!”
Ranked in third place is East Coast Pizzeria, located at 5060 N. High St. in the Sharon Heights neighborhood. The eatery serves brick-fired pizza and flatbreads, along with appetizers, subs, Stromboli, calzones, salad and dessert. Yelp-users compliment its customer service and “flavorful” pizza.
In fourth place is Paulie Gee’s, located at 1195 N. High St. in Victorian Village. Along with wood-fired pizzas including multiple vegan options, the eatery serves soup, salad and bread.
“Paulie Gee's is officially my favorite pizza in Columbus,” one review reads. “Both the wood fired round and deep dish are phenomenal - crust is flavorful, perfect texture with some nice chew, and all the pizzas seem to be topped with hot honey and/or a pile of arugula.”
The fifth highest-rated eatery is Adriatico's New York Style Pizza, located at 1618 Neil Ave. on Ohio State University’s campus. Along with thin and Sicilian pizzas, the restaurant offers appetizers, wings, subs, salad, calzones, pasta and dessert. Reviews praise the pizzeria’s “excellent” service and “huge” pies.
Completing the top 10 best pizzerias in the Columbus area according to Yelp are:
- Moon Pizza, located at 3861 Park Mill Run Dr. in Hilliard.
- Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza, located at 2657 N. High St. in Old North Columbus.
- Dewey’s Pizza, located at 1327 W. 5th Ave.in the Fifth by Northwest neighborhood.
- Gallo’s Pizza, located at 6750 Longshore St. in Dublin.
- Dante’s Pizza, located at 3586 Indianola Ave. in Clintonville.
Yelp develops its rankings based on a variety of factors, including the average star rating, number of reviews and how recent reviews are.
This list is accurate as of Wednesday. Yelp reviews and rankings frequently fluctuate.
